
A good forum is the fastest way to get better at metal detecting. Someone there has already owned the detector you are looking at, dug the ground you are struggling with, or identified the odd lump of lead you have just found. The trouble is knowing which ones are busy, which are friendly to beginners, and what not to post.
This guide covers the UK forums and groups worth your time, what each is best for, and the etiquette that keeps you, your permissions and your finds safe.
The short answer
- Busiest UK forum: the Metal Detecting Forum at metaldetectingforum.co.uk, with over 12,000 members and more than 1.1 million posts when we checked on 10 November 2026.
- For members of the national body: the National Council for Metal Detecting runs a members’ forum, reached through its app and website.
- For identifying a find: search the Portable Antiquities Scheme database first, then ask on a forum with clear photos and a scale.
- For quick answers and photos: Facebook groups and Reddit are busy, but advice is less consistent and posts are harder to search later.
- Before you post anything: never give a findspot, a farm name or a landowner’s name in public.
The main UK forums
The Metal Detecting Forum (metaldetectingforum.co.uk)
This is the largest dedicated UK forum we found. Its own statistics showed 12,239 members, 135,283 topics and 1,114,198 posts on 10 November 2026. That depth is the point: almost any detector, coil, setting or type of find has been discussed before, so the search box often answers a question faster than a new post. It also keeps a list of clubs. You need to register to post.
The NCMD members’ forum
The National Council for Metal Detecting is the hobby’s main representative body in the UK, and membership includes public liability insurance. Members can use its forum through the NCMD app. It is smaller than the open forums, but everyone on it is an insured, signed-up detectorist, which makes it a sensible place for questions about permissions, rallies and reporting. Our insurance guide covers what membership includes.
Detecting.org.uk
A much smaller forum, with 108 members and 783 posts when we looked. It is organised into clear boards for finds, beach detecting, mudlarking, gold panning and coins. Accounts need approval. Worth knowing about, but do not expect a fast reply.
Facebook groups and Reddit
Most day-to-day chat in the hobby now happens in Facebook groups, including groups for single detector models and for individual counties. They are good for quick opinions and for finding local digs. The weaknesses are real, though: advice is not moderated for accuracy, old answers are hard to search, and anything you post is tied to your real name. Reddit’s r/metaldetecting is international, so check that any legal advice is about the UK before acting on it.
Your local club
A club is not a forum, but it does the same job better for local questions: which ground is worked out, which farmers say yes, and who your Finds Liaison Officer is. See our guide to clubs and rallies.
What each one is best for
| You want to… | Best place |
|---|---|
| Research a detector before buying | Metal Detecting Forum search, then our buying guide |
| Identify a coin or artefact | PAS database, then a forum identification board |
| Ask about insurance or the code of practice | NCMD |
| Find a local dig or club | Local Facebook groups, your club |
| Check the law | Primary sources, summarised in our laws guide |
How to ask for an identification
- Clean the find gently, or not at all. Our cleaning guide explains why less is more.
- Photograph both sides in daylight, next to a ruler or a coin for scale.
- Give the size, the weight if you can, and the metal you think it is.
- Give the county at most. Never the parish, field or grid reference.
- Say what you have already ruled out. People help more readily when you have done some work.
Forum etiquette that protects you
- Keep findspots private. A precise location invites people who detect without permission. Record it properly for your Finds Liaison Officer instead.
- Never name a landowner or farm. Permissions are personal and easily lost.
- Do not ask a forum whether you need to report something. Potential treasure must be reported within 14 days. Read what to do if you find treasure and contact your Finds Liaison Officer.
- Be careful buying and selling. Use the forum’s own sales rules, and pay by a method with buyer protection.
- Treat legal advice as opinion. Check it against the sources in our laws guide.
Answering the three questions every beginner asks
New members ask the same three things: what is this find, which detector should I buy, and how do I find the target once I have dug the hole. These answer them before you post.
How we chose: from manufacturers’ specifications and current Amazon UK prices and ratings. We have not tested these ourselves.
For "what is this?": Finds Identified (about £32)
The standard illustrated reference for British detecting finds, written with the Portable Antiquities Scheme. Check it before you ask a forum and you will often have the answer, or at least the right words to describe the object. Rated 4.9 stars from 393 reviews when we checked.
For "which detector?": Minelab Vanquish 340 (about £199)
The cheapest new multi-frequency detector we recommend, and the usual starting point in our buying guides. Our Vanquish 340 review covers who it suits.
For "I cannot find it in the hole": Garrett Pro-Pointer AT (about £117)
A waterproof pinpointer that tells you exactly where the target sits in the plug. Our pinpointer guide has cheaper options from about £40.
Prices and ratings were checked on 10 November 2026 and will have moved.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best metal detecting forum in the UK? For sheer volume of past answers, the Metal Detecting Forum at metaldetectingforum.co.uk, which showed more than 1.1 million posts when we checked. NCMD members also have their own forum.
Are metal detecting forums free? The open forums are free to read and register on. The NCMD forum is for paying members.
Should I post where I found something? No. Give the county at most. Record the exact findspot privately and share it with your Finds Liaison Officer.
Can a forum tell me if my find is treasure? Members can give an opinion, but the legal duty is yours. If a find might be treasure, report it within 14 days.
Is Facebook better than a forum? It is faster and busier, but answers are harder to search later and less reliably checked. Many detectorists use both.